Customer Reviews for Gary's Auto Repair

We love hearing what our customers have to say!

We want you to be completely satisfied with our service, so please let us know how we’re doing.

If you have a review you’d like to share, click the button below and fill out the form below.


Here’s what some of our Delafield, WI customers are saying about us:

  • For years I have taken both my wife's car and my car to Gary's Auto. They are professional and knowledgeable. Recently I had my tires replaced with suggested Michelin Defenders. They are awesome and highly recommended. Gary's auto also has a great warranty package on their tires. I will continue to have both cars serviced there!

    Casey Carney Gary's Auto Customer Review

    I trust Gary's Auto to be helpful, honest, timely, and fair. They have consistently treated me and my vehicle very well!

    Jane Krohn Gary's Auto Customer Review

    Staff is friendly and courteous, service work is great, prices are fair. I have used Gary's Auto for my auto service for 30+ years. Always satisfied. If there is a problem, they make it right.

    Paul Neumiller Gary's Auto Customer Review

    The gentlemen at Gary's were very friendly, professional and completed the job in the timeframe they committed to. They were very thorough and brought to my attention other items that needed immediate repair. Thanks guys for a job well done.

    Scott L. Gary's Auto Customer Review

    Nice and fair technicians. My girlfriend received a proper explanation of the issues on her vehicle and what it would take to fix them. Good job!

    Nickolas Lee Google Review

    Thanks Gary's! 5 Stars from me as well

    Jerry S. Gary's Auto Customer Review

    Gary's has become my go to shop. They can be trusted to do only what's needed! The last repair was diagnosed over a period of time. I had a check engine light that gave several different repairs. Erick cleared the alarm and kept records of it in my file. He researched the fix for the alarm and called me back for the repair. If this isn't professional personal service you tell me what is. I would definitely recommend Gary's for your maintenance and repair needs.

    Mike Butenhoff Gary's Auto Customer Review
  • Gary's always does a great job with our cars. Whenever there is a concern they are willing to help. Dependable, great follow thru and don't leave you waiting for answers!

    Ruth Hytinen Gary's Auto Customer Review

    I've been here twice now and both times the staff is extremely friendly and understanding. When they call about a consult, they explain everything in terms you can understand and aren't the type of mechanics that will attempt to rip you off (like some I've been to). It's a bit of a drive for me to get there, but with how great Gary's Auto is, it's worth it.

    Brittany Fitzgerald Gary's Auto Customer Review

    My car broke down in Oconomowoc at about 1:30 PM. I called 4 places and they all said they couldn't see me that day. I needed emergency repair, and the fifth call went to Gary. Gary's auto took me in, making no promises that I'd be finished that day. I made it clear how important it was and they were willing to keep their technician late just to finish the job. I could not be more pleased with the quality work, timely service, and the willingness to go above and beyond for me. I will always be grateful. Thanks so much.

    Ben M Gary's Auto Customer Review

    Nice guys - they explain everything in the simplest possible way with diagrams and they do service one even showing up on the day something is needed very happy with them

    Lisa Gdaniec Gary's Auto Customer Review

    As usual, Gary's Auto Repair did a great job on my BMW. I can always count on the repairs to be completed with skill and fairly priced.

    Bob Warns Gary's Auto Customer Review

    Gary's Auto is an excellent shop! I highly recommend their services! Each visit has been quick, pleasant and professional, with repairs completed correctly on the first visit. Thank you Gary's Auto!

    Chad Gary's Auto Customer Review
  • Took my car in because it was m aking an odd noise when steering in either direction. Gary's mechanics diagnosed the problem but seeing the car had relatively low miles, Max contacted the dealer to find out the issue was covered under warantee....turns out, it was a waranteed condition. Thanks to Gary's staff for working in my best interest. Instances like this remind me why I've trusted Gary's for so many years. Thanks Gary's & thanks Max.

    Bob G. Gary's Auto Customer Review

    Excellent service for me for last 13 years. Courteous, fair, prompt and highly professional. They have kept my Audi TT (2001) in mint condition. Would not think of going elsewhere.

    Joseph Donofrio Gary's Auto Customer Review

    Excellent service for me for last 13 years. Courteous, fair, prompt and highly professional. They have kept my Audi TT (2001) in mint condition. Would not think of going elsewhere.

    Ted Andersen Gary's Auto Customer Review

    Gary's is definitely the one stop shop. Very personalized staff. If Capy or Max can't get it done for you nobody can. Very competitive on pricing and fast turnaround. The owner is hands on doing the work right next to the other guys. I highly recommend them for all your repair needs.

    Mike Butenhoff Google Review

    They really know what they're doing with European cars! Last year, I took my somewhat smoking and slightly whining Saab to a different repair shop, they couldn't figure out what was wrong and suggested I would need to get a new engine (which would cost more than the car was worth haha). When I got it back, it was smoking heavily, so, I took it to Gary's Auto on a recommendation from a fellow Saab owner at a Hartland gas station. They figured out that the turbo needed replacing. Once they had the part, I quickly got my Saab back with no smoking or whining at an extremely reasonable price! Last month, when my car refused to start and I couldn't diagnose it (checked fuses, battery, fuel pump, no OBDII codes), I got it towed to Gary's and they figured out it was the crankshaft position sensor and it was ready to pick up later that day! Plus, I had a coupon!

    Megan McNally Google Review

    5 Stars!

    Matthew Bringe Google Review

    5 Stars!

    Matthew Bringe Google Review

Add Your Own Review!